
Note: This is not a letter to BRK.
“I just need to get this off my chest, it’s been bothering me. I’m fairly new to WoW, but I seem to be able to hold my own for sure. Yesterday, a group of us guildies, two of which I’d never met before, got together to go help finish up a quest in Arathi for a newer guy. I’m a 43 Hunter, still a baby yes, but I feel confident in my abilities. A 70, who I’d never met before, joined us to help out. So we’re standing there, figuring out coordinates and game plan and the 70 pipes up all the sudden stating how I’m wearing all the wrong clothes. Hmmm….don’t remember asking.
“It just irritates me. Go ahead, inspect, but I don’t think it’s polite to pipe up and start going all ‘I know everything’ when you first meet a person. Am I wrong ladies? How does she/he know if I just happen to pick clothes because I like how they look, it’s no one’s business but my own what I choose to wear. I wasn’t getting killed off and everyone having to wait for me all the time because my gear stinks. I wasn’t getting anyone else killed due to pathetic playing or lack of power. My clothing choice was affecting no one.
“I just recently started being able to wear mail and I’ve been playing around with what seems to work. I understand that them being a 70 means they’ve got more experience in the game, but I’m not really that hard core, I like to take my time, wear what I like and do things for fun. Besides, how does the 70 know that I don’t have a 70 myself, not in that guild or on that realm.
“I just needed to rant about that, I felt that he/she was being very rude and ‘know it all’. Thanks for listening to my complaining gals, you guys are the very best and if I want advice from anyone, I’ll be asking you guys!
“Okay…what should a hunter be wearing? What am I doing so wrong? Here’s what I wearing now.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=B________&n=M_______
“Any input from you guys would be appreciated and welcomed. My husband gave me the rings, so they have sentimental value. c:”
We saw this post on WoWLadies and it made us sit up and pay attention. The writer’s gear-issues were adroitly handled by the denizens, as usual. Dump the Strength and Spirit gear, concentrate on Agility and Stamina, etc.
But there are two things that bothered us. First, nobody bothered to do a talent-spec analysis. Let’s gander at her points:

Thirty-four talent points in the BM tree. Good for going BM, but we need to talk about the distribution, don’t we
Aspect of the Hawk AND Endurance Training is a big No.
Improved Pathfinding is another honkin’ No.
Skipping Improved Mend Pet is a No of the worst order.
Animal Handler in non-raiding situations is also a No.
Skipping Bestial Discipline is a criminal No.
No Frenzy? Can’t get much more No than that.
How should these point be placed? Something like this would be much better for leveling:

The big problems are thusly corrected. The next point completes Unleashed Fury, then the next five complete Serpent’s Swiftness. Bingo bango bungo, you’ve got a helacious DPS-machine built.
Is Ferocious Inspiration critical for leveling? Nah, we could’ve chosen Spirit Bond or Catlike Reflexes and been happy. But this is a much more lethal 34-point killing-machine build than the other, snd that’s what being a hunter is all about.
But the second problem is even more critical than the first.
“My clothing choice was affecting no one.”
Oh it most certainly was affecting someone. It was affecting the wearer’s ability to do her job, it was affecting the rest of her party as they had to carry her weight, and it was affecting her guild, whose reputation was just affected by her choices.
“Dude, I ran this 43 hunter in Pax Vobiscum through some quests, what a mess. How can they let her remain ignorant? Why aren’t they helping her? What’s wrong with Pax Vobiscum?”
And don’t think this doesn’t happen, either.
But the final person it affected was the 70 who felt compelled to help her out, even if he was gruff and clumsy in his delivery.
Is everybody ready to accept criticism? Nope. Are they required to listen to critiques of their gear? No way. Does everybody who offers advice have a bleeping clue what they’re talking about? Ha! No they do not.
But if someone walks up to you and tries to offer some guidance, think about their motives.
“Dude! Ur gear sux!” is indicative of someone not looking to help, but to laugh at your expense. Feel free to /ignore them.
“Did you know that hunter’s don’t get any benefits from Strength? Just because it’s mail, doesn’t mean you should wear it,” is the sign of someone trying to help you.
But why are they trying to help you? Because they feel superior to you and want to rub your nose in your ignorance and laugh? Not usually.
They want to help you because they know what it’s like to get started and not understand the mechanics of the game. WoW can be difficult, as the game does not give you clues as to how to maximize and most efficiently build your toon. One must do research OUT of the game to get the most fun IN the game.
When we see you with +Str on your helm, we know you haven’t done the necessary research. But we assume that you don’t know that you have to do research! That’s why we will do blind tells to people and question them about the gear selections.
“Why do you have a +Str helm?”
“Because it’s the only mail helm I can find.”
“Did you know that a lot of easy-to-get leather helms are better for you at level 43 than most all mail helms?”
“Really?” And the learning begins.
Don’t be too quick to dismiss the legions of WoW Helpers out there, even if they do offer you unrequested advice. Now if he’s a total jerk, please feel free to condemn the messenger.
Just don’t automatically throw his message out with him.